By Elvina Zonagi - Indonesia
Tourism has long been acclaimed as a key driver of economic prosperity, generating jobs and fueling growth for tourism-dependent areas in countless destinations globally. However, this success comes with significant trade-offs, often at the expense of the region’s unique traditions and customs. Venice is a fascinating case study: a city renowned for its breathtaking canals, intricate architecture, and authentic traditions. This article explores the striking case study of Venice, delving into how the relentless pursuit of monetary gain in tourism can destroy cultural authenticity, increase the marketization of social practices, and lead to the mass migration of natives out of their beloved homes.
Tourism’s Economic Allure and Cultural Cost
Venice faces profound difficulties as a result of mass tourism, which has become both a defining feature of the city and a significant strain on its infrastructure and heritage. On average, the city accommodates approximately 215,000 visitors daily, the majority of whom spend only a few hours exploring its iconic locations. This short-lived engagement reduces Venice to a consumable experience, often characterised by the transient interactions. The environmental and infrastructural consequences of this influx are increasingly evident. Trees are cut to make way for urban development, whilst poorly maintained electrical lines emphasise the pressures placed on the city's infrastructure. According to Andrews (2011), the majority of visitors spend a mere few hours in Venice, dashing through the renowned attractions. This leaves them with just enough time to purchase their homogenized travel gifts, all in an effort to take home a piece of the city.
The Displacement of Local Communities
As years went by, these native Venetians were increasingly displaced and replaced by outsiders due to the tourist boom in Venice. These trends have contributed to a steady decline in Venice’s native population, as long-standing residents are increasingly compelled to relocate to more affordable areas. This exodus not only strips the city of its native inhabitants, who form the lifeblood of Venice, but also erodes the generational knowledge embedded within its close knit communities. The relocation of these residents not only signifies a demographic shift, but also the unraveling of Venice’s cultural heritage. The city’s population today has declined to less than 40% of what it was 30 years ago, creating the potential for Venice to transform into a mere historical exhibit - a destination bustling with visitors but devoid of residents actively practicing their genuine way of life. This alienation disperses the various religious and ethnic neighbourhoods of Venice.
The Commodification of Culture
The rise in tourism almost always comes at a cost, as cultural symbols are increasingly commodified - packaged and marketed to satisfy tourist demands. As the saying goes, "There’s no such thing as a free lunch," and the economic advantages of tourism often result in significant trade-offs, including the commercialization of traditions.The commercialization of iconic symbols such as gondola rides, Venetian masks, and glassblowing has become extensive in Venice. This is driven by their portrayed indispensability to mass tourism (Tucker, 2021). Whilst these practices hold significant historical and cultural significance, they are often adapted to align with the demands of international tourism. Unfortunately, this adaptation erodes their authenticity, in order to present what is commonly referred to as "the friendly face of tourism."
The Psychological Impact on Local Identity
Commercialization of the local customs firstly affects the perception of Venice as a tourist destination, but also perhaps more importantly, how the local people regard and carry out their traditions (Liu, 2020). For example, imagine an art or craft that was once integral to a nation or local community becomes a mass-produced export commodity. Such depersonalization often minimises the cultural significance of these traditions, contributing to a sense of alienation among the local population.
Environmental Impact and Cultural Degradation
One consequence of these transformations is a sense of estrangement amongst Venice’s residents, who, despite being true inhabitants of the city, increasingly feel like outsiders in their own home. Those who stay put are often outmatched by visitors, especially in peak season, leading to the impression of performing culture rather than living it wholly. Previously, most public places were used for social interaction but now, they seem to be overpopulated by tourists, thus there is no place for the local activities to take place. This can result in the erosion of local identification, as the specificities of the city are increasingly being altered to cater for the visitors rather than the locals.
As well as the cultural alterations, tourism has its adverse consequences in terms of the environment. An increase in the number of boats navigating the waterways of Venice accelerates the rate of erosion that threatens the priceless historical buildings and delicate structures of the city (Pezzoli, 2017). Furthermore, the high influx of visitors not only leads to congestion but also contributes to environmental pollution, significantly reducing the quality of life for residents. As the natural environment deteriorates, so too does the cultural environment, as sustaining traditional practices and lifestyles becomes increasingly difficult in an overcrowded and polluted city.
A Decreasing Local Population
Moreover, the overwhelming wave of tourism has turned Venice into one of the most expensive cities in Italy, massively contributing to its population decline. Unfortunately, numerous Venetians, unable to sustain a livelihood where they were born and raised, have been left with no choice but to relocate to more affordable areas. (Baker, 2020). As families migrate, schools close, and local businesses shut down, a transformation of a once vibrant and lively community results in nothing but a deserted city.
The decline in Venice's resident population not only dismantles the city’s sense of community, but also threatens the preservation of its cultural traditions. Younger generations are growing up disconnected from the practices and ways of life that once defined their ancestors, resulting in a disruption in terms of the continuity of cultural heritage - one that is exceedingly challenging, if not impossible, to bring back.
The Need for Sustainable Tourism Practices
The inexorable reality is that whilst tourism has revitalized Venice’s economy, it has simultaneously transformed the city’s cultural identity and displaced its residents. The soaring cost of living driven by tourism, coupled with the erosion of local character, represents a significant challenge not only for Venice, but other cities facing similar pressures from high tourist volumes. Therefore, Venice must prioritize sustainable tourism practices that balance the preservation of its cultural heritage with the well-being of its residents, so that the city retains its charming identity for future generations.
Policies aimed at regulating tourist numbers, supporting local businesses, and mitigating environmental damage can effectively address the needs of both visitors and the community. Aside from the practical benefits, efforts to protect Venice’s cultural value are crucial for safeguarding it against the irreversible outcomes from mass tourism. Such measures would reduce the strain caused by excessive tourism whilst encouraging sincere interactions between visitors and residents. This would help Venice maintain its identity as a rich cultural and historic city, rather than diminishing it to a mere ornamental destination.
Bibliography
Andrews, Colman. "Venice As The Tourists Never See It." 2011, https://www.thedailymeal.com/venice-tourists-never-see-it/. Accessed 16 Sept. 2011.
Baker, J. "The Effects of Tourism on Venice: A Cultural Perspective." Journal of Cultural Heritage Management and Sustainable Development, 2020.
Liu, S. "Performing Culture in a Tourist City: Venice and Its Residents." Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change, 2020.
Pezzoli, K. "Environmental Impacts of Mass Tourism: The Case of Venice." Environmental Research Letters, 2017.
Sullivan, R. "Venice: A City Transformed by Tourism." Tourism Management Perspectives, 2019.
Tucker, L. "Commodifying Culture: The Impact of Tourism on Traditional Practices in Venice." Journal of Tourism and Cultural Studies, 2021.
Baud, M., and De Waal, M. Tourism and Urban Development in Venice: The Effects of Mass Tourism on Urban Space. Routledge, 2021.
United Nations World Tourism Organization (UNWTO). Overtourism: Impact and Solutions. United Nations World Tourism Organization, 2020.
Komen